WIBTAH If A Bake Cinnamon Rolls Even If My Older Sister Is Allergic To Cinnamon?

WIBTAH if a bake cinnamon rolls even if my older sister is allergic to cinnamon?

Image credit: Pixabay (This is example image – Not the actual photo)

Family Baking Dilemma: A Holiday Conundrum

When a 17-year-old baking enthusiast is asked to whip up her signature cinnamon rolls for a family Christmas dinner, she faces an unexpected challenge: her older sister’s severe cinnamon allergy. Torn between her love for baking and the desire to include everyone, she contemplates alternative pastries that could also exclude another cousin with a cheese allergy. This relatable story highlights the complexities of family gatherings, where food choices can spark tension and the struggle to accommodate everyone’s needs becomes a heartfelt dilemma.

Family Baking Dilemma During Christmas Dinner

A 17-year-old enjoys baking various treats, including cookies, brownies, churros, and donuts. Recently, they mastered the art of making cinnamon rolls, which have become their specialty. This year, their parents are hosting Christmas dinner, inviting several family members, including:

Maternal uncle and aunt
Three cousins
Maternal grandmother
Father’s cousin with his wife and daughter

With the family gathering approaching, the teenager’s mother requested cinnamon rolls as a dessert. Having made them for family dinners before, the teenager readily agreed. However, a complication arose:

The teenager’s older sister, aged 30, has a severe allergy to cinnamon.
The teenager was unaware that their sister would be attending the dinner.

This situation led to a conflict regarding dessert choices. The teenager felt torn between two options:

Bake cinnamon rolls, which would exclude their sister due to her allergy.
Attempt to bake Golfeados, a traditional Venezuelan pastry similar to cinnamon rolls but made with cheese instead of cinnamon. However, this option posed its own challenges:

The teenager had never baked Golfeados before.
One of their cousins is allergic to cheese, which would also exclude them.

Feeling the weight of the decision, the teenager contemplated the implications of their choice. They had already promised to bake cinnamon rolls, but the thought of excluding their sister weighed heavily on their mind. They questioned whether they would be the “asshole” for proceeding with the cinnamon rolls or if they should attempt the Golfeados despite the risks.

After posting their dilemma online, the teenager received an overwhelming response. They decided to discuss the situation with their sister, which clarified her allergy’s severity. The sister explained that while she cannot eat cinnamon, she would not react to airborne cinnamon or its smell. This revelation allowed the teenager to plan a solution:

Bake a few cinnamon rolls without cinnamon specifically for their sister.

Additionally, the teenager mentioned that their younger sister would be baking a chocolate brownie for the dinner, a tradition they used to share before their older sister moved out. This collaborative effort would help ease the family drama surrounding dessert choices.

In conclusion, the teenager found a way to navigate the wedding tension and family dynamics while ensuring everyone could enjoy the holiday treats. They expressed gratitude for the advice received and wished everyone a happy holiday season.

This is Original story from Reddit

Image credit: Pixabay (This is example image – Not the actual photo)

Story

I, 17, like baking stuff like cookies, brownies, churros, donuts, etcetera. This year, I learned how to bake cinnamon rolls, and I had been baking them at least once every month since July. It had become my specialty.

This year, my parents will host the Christmas dinner in our house, and my maternal uncle, aunt, his wife, and my three cousins will come from another region in my country. Regions are the equivalent to states or provinces. Also, my maternal aunt, my maternal grandmother, and one of my dad’s cousins with his wife and daughter are coming to our house.

My mother asked me if I could bake cinnamon rolls as a dessert for the dinner. It is not the first time I made cinnamon rolls for a family dinner, so I accepted. The thing is, my older sister, 30, F, came from another region to spend Christmas with us, and she is allergic to cinnamon.

I didn’t know she was coming to our house, and I no longer know if I should make cinnamon rolls or not. I feel that if I bake them, I will exclude her. I don’t know if that makes sense, but that’s how I feel.

Then I thought, “I could bake Golfeados,” a traditional Venezuelan pastry that is similar to a cinnamon roll but instead of cinnamon has cheese. It could be a solution, except for two things: 1. I had never baked Golfeados before, and 2. One of my cousins is allergic to cheese; it is not the same thing as being lactose intolerant.

If I bake cinnamon rolls, I will exclude my sister, but if I bake Golfeados, I will exclude my cousin, or at least that is how I feel. I can’t turn back because I already promised I would bake cinnamon rolls or Golfeados for Christmas. Considering I have never baked Golfeados before, I will probably bake cinnamon rolls.

So, would I be the AH?

EDIT

I didn’t expect so many answers in less than two hours! I’m very surprised, and I want to add some things.

I want to thank everyone who took their time to read and answer this post. I read every comment and suggestion you left.
I talked to my sister about the topic, something I should have done before posting this, lol. I knew she’s allergic to cinnamon, but I didn’t know how severe her allergy was before I asked. According to her, she can’t eat cinnamon, but only that; she will not have a reaction if the cinnamon is airborne or if she smells it. So, I’ll bake a few rolls without cinnamon for her.
For the people that suggested I should bake something else, I want to add that my younger sister is going to bake a chocolate brownie for the dinner with me, and our older sister, like the three of us used to do years ago before my older sister moved out of the house.

Without anything else to add, I hope everyone has nice holidays. Bye.

View the Original Reddit Post Here

Summary of Reddit Comments

The top Reddit comments reveal a strong consensus around the idea that making a dessert containing cinnamon would be harmful due to the allergy of the sister. Users emphasize the importance of considering health risks and suggest alternatives to avoid any potential allergic reactions, highlighting a collective concern for the sister’s well-being.

Verdict: YWBTA (You Would Be The AH)

Expert Advice for Resolving the Family Baking Dilemma

It’s commendable that you are considering the feelings and health of your family members while navigating this baking dilemma. Here are some practical steps to help you resolve the conflict while ensuring everyone can enjoy the holiday treats:

Communicate Openly: Start by having an open conversation with your older sister about her allergy. Understanding the severity and specifics of her condition will help you make an informed decision. Since she mentioned that she can tolerate the smell, this is a crucial detail to consider.
Plan for Inclusivity: Since your sister can’t eat cinnamon but is not affected by its smell, you can bake cinnamon rolls for the family while also preparing a special batch without cinnamon for her. This way, you honor your promise while ensuring she feels included.
Collaborate with Your Younger Sister: Since your younger sister is also baking brownies, consider making this a team effort. You can both create a dessert table that features a variety of treats, ensuring that there are options for everyone. This can help foster a sense of togetherness during the holiday.
Explore Alternative Recipes: If you still want to try making Golfeados, consider doing a small test batch beforehand. This will give you a chance to practice and see if it’s a viable option for the dinner. Just be mindful of your cousin’s cheese allergy and perhaps create a cheese-free version if you decide to go this route.
Prepare for Future Gatherings: To avoid similar dilemmas in the future, consider discussing dietary restrictions with family members ahead of time. This can help everyone plan better and ensure that all guests feel included and safe during family gatherings.

By taking these steps, you can navigate the complexities of family dynamics while ensuring that everyone enjoys the holiday treats. Remember, the goal is to create a warm and inclusive atmosphere where all family members feel valued and cared for. Happy baking!